Viral violence read more

Facebook’s live problem

Graphic video of Cleveland murder is yet another example of viral violence on Facebook

Graphic video of Cleveland murder is yet another example of viral violence on Facebook

On Easter Sunday, Cleveland-area health clinic worker Steve Stephens apparently shot and killed 74-year-old Robert Godwin Sr., recorded a video of the alleged murder, and then posted it on Facebook, where it stayed up several hours before it was removed. At some point during the day he also broadcasted a message on Facebook Live, but it was unclear what he said, and his account has now been deactivated.

The incident once again brought unwelcome attention to Facebook Live, a feature that the social network has aggressively hyped over the past year, but which has been marred by a string of killings, assaults and other acts of violence. Facebook has said that while Live can can provide “a window into the best moments in people’s lives, it can also let us bear witness to the worst.” Godwin’s death raises, not for the first time, the question of how quickly Facebook deals with the “worst.”

“We work hard to keep a safe environment on Facebook, and are in touch with law enforcement in emergencies when there are direct threats to physical safety,” Facebook said in a statement to VICE News Sunday night.

This undated photo provided by the Cleveland Police shows Steve Stephens. (Cleveland Police via AP)

As of Monday, a manhunt spanning the Midwest was underway, with law enforcement advising people in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Indiana, Michigan, and New York to be on the lookout for Stephens. At a police press conference, Cleveland Police Chief Calvin D. Williams said that “the last location we actually had [Stephens] at was the homicide. Anything else right now is kind of speculation.”

In the year that Facebook Live has been available to all Facebook users, it has captured a number of stomach-churning events. Some more recent incidents include:

  • Shortly after New Year’s, four teens in Chicago filmed themselves on Live torturing a mentally disabled man, who was later found walking the streets of the city. The group was later charged with a hate crime.
  • A mid-February killing of three in Chicago that was caught on camera by a woman broadcasting herself at the time of the shooting.
  • A sexual assault in late March that was committed by multiple assailants. The stream was viewed by a few dozen people as it was occurring, none of whom reported the incident to authorities. The victim’s mother reached out to police directly after she had been missing for hours.

For almost a year now, Facebook’s public line about graphic content broadcast on Live has been that Facebook gives us both the “best” and the “worst” of what people put on Facebook. That statement, released last July, came two days after a Facebook Live stream captured the aftermath of the police shooting of Minneapolis man Philando Castile, whose death provoked protests nationwide.

This past November, in part because of evidence drawn from the Live broadcast, the officer who shot Castile to death was charged with manslaughter.

Asked about whether Facebook was considering changes to Live because of the Stephens incident or other violent encounters, a company spokesperson said they would get back to VICE News when they had more information.

 

M-F 7:30PM HBO